How the frak did Darren Criss win this? The guy looks like he's got caterpillars on his face and a mop on his head. Gaspard looks like a serial killer and Andrew Garfield looks too sweet and passive (though not my Remus, either).

Aaron Johnson all the way. Well, only in the Nowhere Boy era. Cause before that he had flat brown hair with the angsty tween sideswept bangs, and afterwards he grew the pervy moustache and the clown hair. And then dyed it all blonde... why...

Jude Law would just be awesome. :3

I might have been reading too much fanfiction, but I pictured Nicholas Hoult because of his trademark lopsided smile plus he's British

Gaspard Ulliel is perfect James. Absolutely.

I chose Aaron, although he's not exactly the James I've got in mind when I read the books.

none >.> They just don't fit with my idea of James, I guess. Maybe A.G. if he dyed his hair...?

Aaronnnnn~